Roof Replacement for Shirley Homeowners

Financing provided by Slice, Foundation Finance, Regions. Subject to credit approval. Rates, terms, and promotional periods are set by the lender and disclosed in writing before you sign.

Recent Shirley Roofing Projects

5 before-and-after projects documented for the homeowner and the homeowners insurance carrier.

Cut-Up Rooflines Around Shirley

Some houses are essentially one big plane with a ridge across the top, and some look like several roofs that happen to share an address. The second kind takes longer, costs more to do properly, and hands water many more chances to find a way in.

Valleys are the main reason. Where two planes meet, everything that lands on both of them funnels into a single channel, and the volume moving through there during a hard rain is far greater than anything the open field ever sees.

Dormers put walls on a roof, and any place a roof runs into a wall needs step flashing woven in course by course as the shingles go on. Where that wall ends at the eave, a kick-out piece has to throw the water out into the gutter instead of behind the trim. It's a small bent piece of metal that gets skipped constantly, and the damage it prevents is expensive, because the water goes down inside the wall cavity where nobody notices it for a long time.

Then there are the shallow pieces. Porch roofs, sunroom additions, and the section over a bay window often sit at a pitch too low for standard shingles to shed the way they need to. Those areas call for a different covering, or at absolute minimum a full membrane beneath, and a bid that treats them exactly like the steep part of the house is either careless or counting on you not to ask.

All of this shows up as time. A busy roof means more starter course, longer ridge and hip runs, more waste from cutting into valleys, and far more hours spent on detail that a simple gable never asks for.

When you compare written estimates on a house like that, look at whether the flashing and the shallow slope work are called out on their own lines. If they're folded into one number with everything else, you have no way to know whether they were priced or simply forgotten.

Taking Your Time After the Inspection

When the visit ends you should be under no more obligation than you were before we pulled up. That isn't a courtesy line. It's the only sensible way to sell a roof, because a homeowner who felt pushed spends the whole job waiting to be taken advantage of, and that's a miserable few days for everybody involved.

So the estimate goes to you with a date on it and a plain note about what could move the pricing, usually material cost changes rather than anything to do with you. Take it to whoever you talk to about money.

Sleep on it through a couple of weekends if that's what you need. We follow up once, maybe twice, and then we leave it alone until you get in touch.

We expect you to get other bids, and we would rather you did. What we ask is that you compare them on the same terms. Look at whether each one states the layers coming off, whether there's a decking allowance with a rate attached, whether flashing is itemized by location or hidden in a lump, and whether the ventilation plan is written down.

A bid that leaves all of that blank usually isn't the cheaper one at all. It has simply moved the decisions to a day when the roof is already open and you have very little room to argue about anything.

If you want help reading somebody else's proposal, bring it to us and we'll go through it with you honestly, including the parts where their approach is defensible or plainly better than ours. We have pointed homeowners toward another company more than once when the fit was clearly better, and we have never regretted it. A roof stays on a house for a long time, and choosing who builds it is worth a couple of weeks of ordinary thinking instead of one evening under pressure.

Call with as many questions as you want while you work through it. Nobody here keeps score of how long a homeowner takes to decide.

Ask Who Is Actually on Your Shirley Roof

If you only get one question, make it this one. Roofing is labor before it's anything else, and the difference between a roof that lasts its full life and one that leaks in the third year almost always comes down to the hands that installed it rather than the bundle it came out of. So ask directly whether the people who will be on your house are employees of the company you're hiring or a crew brought in for the season.

Neither answer is automatically wrong. Plenty of good work gets done by long standing crews who aren't on the payroll. What matters is the relationship.

Ask how long this particular lead has run jobs for them, how many houses they did together last year, and whether the same lead will be on your roof from the first bundle to the final walk. Ask who supervises during the day, how often that person is on site, and whether anyone from the office will look at the work before you're asked to pay.

The follow up question is about language and communication. If the lead doesn't speak much English and the salesman is gone by mid morning, you need to know who you actually talk to when you notice something from the ground.

Good companies solve this easily and will tell you exactly how. Ones that haven't thought about it will get uncomfortable, which is itself an answer.

While you're at it, ask about insurance in the plain sense. Does the company carry liability coverage and workers coverage for everyone who will be on your property, and can they have the carrier send you a certificate directly instead of a copy out of their own files. If somebody gets hurt on your roof and the answer to that question was no, the problem becomes yours, and it is a very unpleasant way to learn about the way your contractor runs a business.

Why a Cheap Shirley Bid Is Cheap

A bid well below the others is not a mystery, and it is usually not generosity. Something has been left out, and since almost none of it is visible once the roof is finished, the difference doesn't show up until later.

The most common omission is the tear-off. Going over the existing roof saves a day of labor and an entire disposal bill, and it also means nobody looks at the deck, the new fasteners never reach solid wood, and the whole assembly carries weight it wasn't framed for.

The next place to look is the deck line. A bid with no decking allowance isn't a bid that expects good wood. It is a bid that has moved that conversation to the day when your roof is open, the dumpster is in the driveway and rain is coming.

The same trick shows up with flashing. Reusing the existing metal at a chimney or a sidewall saves real money and real hours, and it puts decades old material under a brand new roof, which is where the leak will come from.

The details thin out from there. Starter course replaced by cut up field shingles. Ice membrane reduced to a narrow strip or skipped entirely.

Ridge caps cut from three tab material rather than the proper piece. Nothing at all done about ventilation. Fewer fasteners per shingle than the instructions call for, which is invisible until a wind event and also quietly voids the material coverage you thought you were buying.

And then there's what stands behind the price. Insurance that does not cover everyone on the roof, no permit pulled where the town wanted one, no office to call in a few years, and a workmanship promise from a company that changes names every couple of seasons.

We are not the cheapest bid on most houses and we don't try to be. What we'll do is tell you precisely what is in ours, so you can find out what's missing from the other one.

When the Install Calendar Fills Up

Roofing work is not spread evenly through the year, and knowing the rhythm can save you a fair amount of waiting. The quiet stretch is the deep part of winter, when the phone is mostly repairs and emergency calls. That's the ideal time to have an inspection done and a scope written for work you intend to have done later, because nobody is rushed and you can take your time with the decision.

Things tighten in a hurry once spring weather arrives. If a hail event comes through the area, every company within driving distance fills their calendar within days, and out of town crews show up to soak up the overflow.

Homeowners who wait until then to start getting bids end up choosing from whoever has an opening instead of from whoever they wanted. If your roof is already on borrowed time in the fall, getting the paperwork settled over the winter puts you near the front of the line once spring arrives.

Summer runs steady and predictable, which is why it's the easiest season to schedule with confidence. Days are long enough that most houses go up and get dried in the same day, and the weather cooperates often enough that reschedules are rare. The tradeoff is that everyone else has figured this out too, so lead times in the middle of the season are usually the longest of the year.

Autumn is a scramble. Everybody who has been putting it off wants their roof done before winter, and the daylight is shrinking while the list is growing. We keep installing as long as conditions allow, and there is nothing wrong with a cold weather install done properly, but the window narrows and the flexibility disappears.

If you know you need a roof, the cheapest thing you can do is decide early. Nothing about the work itself costs more in a hurry, but the waiting does. A scope written in the quiet part of the year also holds its shape better than one put together in a parking lot the week after a hailstorm.

Serving Every Part of Shirley

Roofing projects completed across Shirley's neighborhoods and surrounding areas. Click any neighborhood for the specifics we have learned working there.

Where we respond near Shirley

Indiana-licensed crews dispatched to Shirley and the closest surrounding communities.